Basta barriques: a conversion of Constantine?

Earlier this month, Maremma producer of Morellino di Scansano and Syrah Gianpaolo Paglia (above, winemaker and owner of Poggio Argentiera, with his family) authored a short post on his blog entitled simply Basta barrqiues, enough with barriques.

In the post he informs his readers that he no longer intends to age his Sangiovese and Ciliegiolo in barriques, small new oak French barrels.

He explains: “In the last 10-15 years, the world of wine has changed. And, above all, my (and our) tastes have changed. This is no disavowal of the past, no repudiation. It’s very simple: one evolves, as a person and as a company.” (translation mine)

Yesterday, Italian wine blogger extraordinaire Mr. Franco Ziliani, who has long exhorted a more moderate use of barrique aging among Italian winemakers, posted an interview with Giampaolo.

Here are a few passages I found interesting and have translated from Gianpaolo’s answers:

    In certain wines produced with barriques, there is an excessive sweetness. However much this can be viewed in positive light, I find that it tires the palates. Complexity and nuance tend to be lost, trumped by a certain creaminess in the taste of the wine. Generally, I believe that it is more difficult draw out the character of grapes like Sangiovese and Ciliegiolo, where a certain angularity and backbone form the basis of their identity. And then there’s also the drinkability factor: I’m tired of drinking overly invasive wines.

    I can tell you that making wines that will be enjoyed by people who make wine makes much more commercial sense than trying to interpret the tastes of the market. My impression is that we tend not to fully appreciate people who buy wines and drink them. This is probably due partly to a lack of awareness and partly — and perhaps mostly — due to our lack of courage.

    There are wines that seem excellent to us but we consider them “difficult” for the market. But, then again, we discover that the market is very open to good wines, real wines, expressive wines. I see this every day, especially since I began to sell wines beyond the wines I produce.

I’m excited to taste the new vintages of Poggio Argentiera and I really admire Gianpaolo for the honesty and forthrightness of his blog and his words (he is, btw, probably the top Italian winemaker/blogger and his use of social media as a tool to promote his wines is world-class).

One of the most vocal opponents of barrique aging of Sangiovese I know is my friend Charles Scicolone, who began drinking Nebbiolo and Sangiovese in the 1970s. “They’ll crucify me on a cross made of barrique,” he likes to say humorously.

It’s too early to tell but could Gianpaolo’s declaration be an early sign of a conversion of Constantine? Let’s hope so… Chapeau bas, Gianpaolo!

In other good news…

It seems that Mr. Ziliani has returned from his blogging hiatus.

4 thoughts on “Basta barriques: a conversion of Constantine?

  1. Ciao Jeremy- Very interesting. I can only hope that Italian producers will stop making wines they “think” the maket wants and make the best wines they can and wines that they drink themselves. Just before the
    Battle of the Milivan Bridge a burning cross appeared to the “Emperor” Constantine and it said “In This Conquer”. I would hope the burning cross was made from
    barriques. In 2002 I went to visit Bartolo Mascarello and I can still here him saying ” No barriques,no cabernet,no chardonnary and no wines with made up names”. “Barriques are for baracades not wine” I very
    proudly own a shrit with Bartolo’s picture on it which says on the back “No Barriques No Berlusconi” He will be missed. William Jennings Bryan “Do not crucify me to a cross of gold’ He was right in the long run and I hope soon I will no longer have to be cruified on a cross of barrique when I drink wine. Thanks for remembering

  2. Thank you very much Jeremy for translating part of Ziliani’s post on my decision. I’m very glad to see that this has stirred an interesting conversation on Italian blogs about the current state of the art of Italian wines and their future. I think that we are now in the position to devote our efforts to a better knowledge of our land, our vineyards, our tecniques of production, or in other words, our terroir. For the last decade I’ve been on a learning curve, of which barriques and a certain style of wine were part, now I feel I have to move further to find the true expression of my land in my wines.
    It’s going to take time, because nothing is fast when it comes to agricolture, but I’m sure I’m on the right path. How do I know it? Simply because I started to love my wines again.

  3. Jeremy:

    It’s one thing for Charles, Franco, you, myself and some other journalists to continue our push for traditional wines aged in large casks. But when a top Italian winemaker sends out the message that barrique are not a good thing, that is very encouraging!

    Congratulations to Gianpaolo for this and let’s hope many more winemakers (especially in Tuscany) follow his lead.

  4. Pingback: Life after barrique: “I started to love my wines again” « Do Bianchi

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s