“Some of my best friends are Jewish” in Trump America

rubenstein-jewish-community-center-houstonAbove: the Evelyn Rubenstein Jewish Community Center of Houston, not far from where we live.

“[Bomb] threats, which turned out to be unfounded, were reported all over the Eastern United States on Monday [January 9, 2017], at as many as 16 Jewish community facilities” (New York Times).

“There were as many as 27 bomb threats on Wednesday [January 18, 2017] at Jewish centers in 17 states, according to the J.C.C. Association of North America” (New York Times).

“Ivanka Trump took to Twitter to call for religious tolerance following the latest wave of bomb threats that were made against 11 Jewish community centers Monday [February 20, 2017]” (FoxNews).

Tracie P and I learned about this third, most recent wave of coordinated bomb threats not from Fox or the New York Times. It came to our attention because Tracie was on the way to the super market where we regularly shop in our southwest Houston neighborhood, which happens to be in one of the city’s heavily Jewish areas, Westbury. The Rubenstein Jewish Community Center is on her route to the store and its members were among the victims of these orchestrated acts of terror.

It was only after his daughter posted her tweet on February 20 that President Trump acknowledged that there has been a rise of anti-Semitic episodes and terror in recent months.

As late as February 15, 2017, when asked to comment on the rise of open anti-Semitism in the U.S. at a joint news conference with Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu, Trump answered as follows:

“Well, I just want to say that we are very honored by the victory that we had — 306 Electoral College votes. We were not supposed to crack 220. You know that, right? There was no way to 221, but then they said there’s no way to 270. And there’s tremendous enthusiasm out there.”

Don’t believe me? Read a transcript of the conference on WhiteHouse.gov.

As late as February 16, 2017, when asked by a reporter about the rise of open anti-Semitism in the U.S., President Trump told the journalist that it was “an insulting question” and never answered the question. Don’t believe me? Watch the clip from C-Span. (Trump’s insensitivity and evasion of the question were made even more mind-boggling by the fact that the reporter asking the question was an orthodox Jew.)

Then, on Tuesday, February 21, 2017, President Trump addressed the issue directly for the first time when he told NBC News, “I will tell you that anti-Semitism is horrible, and it’s going to stop and it has to stop.”

“This felt like something of a reset,” noted a FoxNews reporter, “for a president who has been battered by negative headlines and management missteps during his first month in office.”

Until the February 21 statement, Trump had repeatedly avoided answering questions about the rise of open anti-Semitism by invoking his Jewish family members and Jewish friends.

In the February 15 news conference, he noted that “as far as people — Jewish people — so many friends, a daughter who happens to be here right now, a son-in-law, and three beautiful grandchildren.”

I don’t think that the president is anti-Semitic in his heart. After all, he’s a New Yorker: he was famously mentored by a gay Jewish man and has many famous Jewish friends, not to mention the fact that his daughter married into one of New York’s leading Jewish families and that she had converted to Judaism before their marriage.

And I am not going to speculate as to why he hasn’t robustly and wholeheartedly condemned anti-Semitism until now.

But I believe that as a role model for all Americans, his insistence on avoiding the question of anti-Semitism in our nation is abominable and dangerous.

I fear that his avoidance of the question might be interpreted by some Americans as acquiescence. And I’m not the only member of the Jewish community in America who is deeply troubled by his seeming reluctance to face the issue and speak out.

Having Jewish business associates, Jewish friends, and Jewish family members doesn’t absolve any honest American — let alone the president! — from standing up and speaking out against hatred.

Some of my best friends are Jews, too. I know they’ll be glad, like me, to see that President Trump is finally doing the right thing. What took you so long, Mr. President? What took you so long, friend?

6 thoughts on ““Some of my best friends are Jewish” in Trump America

  1. You cannot just singled out anti semitism. Mohammad Ali’s son being held last week for two-hours at Miami’s airport’ questioning him on his religious beliefs and background. People are getting comments for wearing a hijab. Also in reverse, people making comments about the Christian majority in this country generalizing the Christian movement as oppressive. At the end of the day it’s religious tolerance that needs to be stressed here for all faiths.

  2. Tony, I agree with you 500 percent. But in this post I wanted to address something that affects me and my family personally. Candidate Trump’s embrace of intolerance and President Trump’s reluctance to denounce intolerance are un-American, un-Christian, and counter to everything our country stands for.

  3. In Trump’s America – Trumps daughter and son-in-law are Jewish. His comments which you quoted were a partial response to a question referring to his presidential victory… if you you extend the actual quote (and Q asked) you will see that to be true. Religious tolerance in this country on the left and the right is necessary for a harmonious USA to be at peace with itself. That being said, this is not a left or right issue, it is an issue of acceptance and tolerance, even when intolerance and silencing our freedom of speech and religion is at the forefront of many on the left/right. We (Jeremy, Tony, Tracy, I… et al) are the ones who need to speak up and recount what we see, “accurately and with tolerance” for our fellow brothers/sisters… including fairness and accuracy in regards to our president. We owe that to each other and ourselves to be taken seriously in the discourse of civility and truth.

    • Charlie, where does Trump condemn anti-Semitism in the transcript of the news conference Q&A? I can’t find it. Please send me the passage.

      Adrian, I’ve been fascinated with Roy Cohn ever since Angeles in America. He used to eat at Tony’s in Houston!

  4. Whether he’s an anti-semite or not, his reluctance to speak out against such heinous acts emboldens those who perpetrate them. For example, on Holocaust Remembrance Day, his statement did not acknowledge the Jews who perished in WWII because that would be “unfair” to the others who died. What a load of crap! Waiting so long to make what was, at best, a tepid response to the violence, was unbecoming of a U.S. President.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s