On the internet trolls trolling our souls. Is the mitigation of truth really worth the subjugation of our psyche?

For many of us committed to maintaining an online presence, and especially for those devoted to writing about politics, trolls have become an inescapable part of life’s everyday fabric.

In my early years as a wine writer, I learned a lot about trolling from at least three wine elders who couldn’t countenance my presence in their world. It was a crash course in how the anonymous internet can reveal people’s true nature.

The ills and dangers of trolls only grew when America’s troll-in-chief took office a decade ago.

These days, my political posts get hundreds of comments from people I don’t know. My friends often share their concern about my mental health in the face of so many unbridled detractors. But it doesn’t bother me: if I can survive “the Italian wine guy” (who tried in every which way to take me down), I can survive just about anything.

But it is awful to see how my friends perceive the comments. Alarmed by the attacks on me, they often come to my defense and get wrapped in back-and-forth battles with my denigrators.

It may still come as a surprise to some that an overwhelming number of the commenters are bots. Every time I see my comment thread growing like that, I challenge a few of the users to prove they are real people. Most of them have nearly vacant Facebooks and one of them even admitted to me the other day that they were a bot. Many of their Facebooks disappear days after they post on my page. Occasionally, I find a real person among them. But most of them are either AI agents or people who are paid to troll social media users.

The bottom line is that they have been hired or created to intimidate people like me from writing about their political and cultural views. It was particularly bad every time I wrote about Talarico.

A recent episode of coordinated malevolent trolling in our community was devastating to a beloved elementary teacher. The teacher’s cultural crime? They had posted their thoughts about the results of the midterms. The post was picked up by a highly visible TikTok troll and then later amplified by Donald Trump’s Facebook.

I don’t know the teacher personally but I know an educator who knows them well. I was told that the teacher and their family faced death threats. The school where they worked had to be locked down on multiple days because of bomb threats. The school’s crisis management ultimately had to scrub their internet presence to protect them.

What was the point of the trolling? Evidently, to stop a school teacher in Texas from sharing their feelings about the election.

I can’t get through a week without being trolled for something I’ve written. But someone like that teacher doesn’t have the thick skin I’ve grown over the years of facing wine elders, white supremacists, and now Islamophobes, transphobes, and xenophobes.

That teacher will never get their Facebook back. Think about that: they lost access to family photos, among other cherished media, because someone decided that they didn’t like what they had written on the internet. They and their family will be emotionally scarred for life. And they will most likely never share their political views in public again.

None of this would have happened had a troll not been trolling the internet searching for views that would trigger their fans. I believe and trust that the teacher will recover and I know that their school is giving them the resources they need to get to the other side of this. But their life will never be the same. They will also be wondering where the next attack could appear.

Scholars will wrangle for decades about the how, why, and because of the Trump era. But there’s one thing we can all agree on: Trump and his like have made the absence of empathy a virtue in their world.

And speaking to those of you who subscribe to Trump’s worldview, was the ruination of an upstanding community member’s life worth the pleasure you get in censoring them? If the answer is yes, then troll your soul away.

Leave a Reply