I am also not accusing Jeremy of calling me a Nazi. Jeremy knows my anti-Nazi credentials are impeccable and would never stoop so low.

Even Traci B., God Bless her, is innocent of all charges of Nazi-ism or accusing others of Nazi sympathies.

I hope the estate moves to organic farming in the future and I would also like to see a lower dose of sulpher in some of the bottlings.

Regardless, the key thing about the estate is their wonderful holdings, their insistence on hand harvesting, and the preponderance of selections massale in their vineyards, rather than clones.

I gladly drink this wine and drank a 1997 and 2000 L d’Or this summer.

It is not dogmatically correct but is still delicious.

But it is not really a naturally made wine as it stands now. We hope it will be in the future.

The paradox of viticulture is that someone with inferior holdings might do everything “right” and the wine may not even approach Luneau’s wines because they have clones and bad terroir. Life is long and we hope Luneau and his Pierre-Marie will move to an organic production soon. We are doing all we can to bring this about.

For me, the leaders in Natural wine Muscadet are Guy Bossard, Jo Landron, and Marc Ollivier.

You create a strawman through a lack of research, knock it down, and claim the higher moral ground because you are not a dogmatist.

I’m not telling you if you should or should not like the Domaine Salvert Cheverny. That’s your judgement.

But why drag everyone into a totally unnecessary argument based on your lack of research.

Enjoy the wines you like, be they soaked with Monsanto products, sustainable, organic, industrial or just plain shitty. Or even natural.

Just, please, don’t try to stake a higher ground for yourself and Stacy B. Soon, I’ll have to read how you are being persecuted.